Replacing dairy products with plant-based alternatives could reduce the average intake of iodine and other essential micronutrients, suggests a modelling study by researchers at Queen’s University Belfast and the University of Surrey, published this morning in The Lancet Planetary Health journal.
The model, which used UK data, estimated that the average iodine intake would be reduced by between 9% and 21% if a third of dairy products were replaced with a plant-based alternative, and by 13% to 28% if half were replaced. However mandatory fortification of plant-based dairy alternatives with iodine, and adding iodised salt to bread, would counteract this reduction.
The All Ireland Science Media Centre asked experts to comment on the implications of the study for Irish populations.
Dr Anne Nugent, Reader and Registered Public Health Nutritionist, Institute for Global Food Security, School of Biological Sciences, Queens University Belfast, comments:
Note: Dr Nugent is an author of the study
“Although we used UK data, our study is directly relevant for the island of Ireland for two reasons. Firstly, our analysis included dietary data for individuals living in Northern Ireland as recorded in the National Diet and Nutrition Survey. But we know from existing research that similar low iodine intakes exist for adolescent females and women of child bearing age for the entire island. Secondly, the alternative products we included in the modelling featured many which are on sale in both the UK and in Ireland. Similar to our market survey, inconsistencies in fortification practices of such products have been reported for Ireland.
“The island of Ireland is also vulnerable to iodine insufficiency due to a lack of an iodine fortification policy , particularly if there is a shift to intakes of plant based dairy alternatives that are not fortified. For teenagers, however, the recently published Healthy Eating Guidelines for Adolescents in Ireland acknowledges that where chosen, adolescent males require options fortified with calcium and for adolescent females to choose options fortified with iodine and calcium.”
Declaration of interest: “AN has received an honorarium from Dairy Council NI and the European Milk Forum for delivering a lecture for health care professionals and the National Dairy Council (Ireland) for writing a research article for health care professionals. She has a small farm holding (<15ha, sheep and beef) in the Republic of Ireland. She is a member of the Public Health Nutrition Subcommittee at the Food Safety Authority of Ireland (voluntary role), and was a member of the working group that developed the new Healthy Eating Guidelines for Adolescents in Ireland. She is a Registered Nutritionist (Public Health) and a member of the Nutrition Society and a Visiting Associate Professor at the School of Agriculture and Food Sciences at University College Dublin.”
Dr Janette Walton, NutRI Research Group, Munster Technological University; Lead investigator, National Dietary Surveys in Ireland, comments:
“This study has particular relevance for the Irish population particularly the nutritional health of teenage girls and women of childbearing age.
“With dietary guidelines now recommending a large shift from animal-based diets to more plant-based diets in response to meeting global sustainability goals, unintended consequences for the health of teenage girls and young women must be considered.
“The study using dietary data from the UK population investigated the potential impact of switching consumption of dairy products (milk, yogurt & cheese) (long recognised for their high nutrient value) to plant-based dairy alternatives (PBDA) (which vary in nutrient composition) on micronutrient adequacy in the UK population.
“The study showed the large impact that meeting sustainability goals would have on iodine intake in the UK with a reduction of 13–28% of current intakes (which are already low in certain groups). Iodine is an important nutrient with a critical role in thyroid function and cognitive development. Low iodine intake can have considerable health consequences, particularly during pregnancy and early life.
“This study is of particular significance to the Irish population as low iodine intakes in teenage girls and women of childbearing age in Ireland has already been highlighted as a concern that needs to be actioned.
“The study found that mandatory PBDA fortification prevented declines in micronutrient intake, however iodine inadequacy remained high among adolescent females (59% inadequate). Iodine-fortified bread improved iodine intake, reducing inadequacy among adolescent females to 37%. Fortification practices in Ireland are similar to that in the UK hence the findings of this study are very applicable.
“The authors conclude that proactive policy action such as mandatory fortification of PBDAs and the use of iodised salt in bread would be needed to ensure that climate-aligned food systems do not compromise public health. This holds true for Ireland also.”
Declaration of interest: Member of FSAI Scientific committee subgroup (Public Health Nutrition). Our research group at Munster Technological University has received grants from the food sector including Danone and Kellanova and policy makers such as the Dept. of Health and the FSAI to conduct specific pieces of research of relevance to the stakeholder/policy maker.
Professor Mairead Kiely, Cork Centre for Vitamin D and Nutrition Research, School of Food and Nutritional Sciences and INFANT Centre, University College Cork, comments:
“Vitamins and minerals that are supplied by animal source foods will need to be replaced in a transition to diets that substantially reduce intakes of these foods and replace them with plant-based alternatives. Plant-based dairy alternatives (PBDA), unless fortified appropriately, do not contain equivalent amounts of calcium, iodine, riboflavin and vitamin B12 as milk, yoghurt and cheese.
“Nutrients such as iodine and calcium are already in short supply in the usual diet of people who avoid dairy, and are therefore of public health concern. Certain population groups, especially adolescents and women of reproductive age already have low intakes of calcium, iodine and riboflavin. While moderate population-based reductions in dairy are unlikely to cause problems for most people, among those who already consume little, reductions will further reduce the already inadequate intakes of these nutrients.
“Using high-quality representative dietary intake data from the UK, Nicol and colleagues present a thoughtful modelling exercise to address the question of what would happen to iodine, calcium, riboflavin and vitamin B12 intakes if milk and dairy were replaced by plant-based dairy alternatives and how might the problem be addressed. The results showed that even partial replacement of dairy products with PBDA reduced intakes of calcium, iodine and riboflavin among adolescents and women of reproductive age. Fortification of PBDA at minimum minimised the impact on iodine in particular.
“Unlike many European countries, the UK and Ireland do not implement an iodine fortification policy, which has been shown to increase the risk of mild to moderate iodine deficiency during pregnancy. Iodine is required in sufficient quantities during pregnancy to ensure healthy fetal brain development.
“Due consideration to the introduction of iodine fortification is required. Widespread use of unfortified PBDA is likely to increase micronutrient deficiency.”
Declaration of interest: “I have received research funding from European Union’s Horizon Europe Research and Innovation Programme (Grant agreement no. 101287404 and no. 101287404, both co-funded by UK Research and Innovation) as well as Research Ireland, Wellcome Leap, Irish Government Dept of Agriculture Food and the Marine, Enterprise Ireland, and Meat Technology Ireland, which is less that 5% of my total funding envelope.”
